Skip to content

My Kids; Your Kids

16 November 2008

broken_family1It is often said that the Republican Party is the “Daddy Party” and the Democratic Party is the “Mommy Party.”  The financial meltdown is giving real definition to this concept.  The problem with Mommy and Daddy is that they don’t have any children in common.  They are more like a marriage between two people each with their own children from a previous marriage.  And neither seems particularly inclined to help the other’s children.  Now, in fairness the Democrats were far more open to the idea of helping the Republican children, banks and insurance companies, than the Republicans have been in helping the Democrat children, auto industries and workers.

paulson-bush-rtWhile Hank Paulsen has been directing the big trucks of Wall Street banks and insurance companies to back on up to the loading docks down at the U.S. Treasury, he and his boss, George W. Bush have put up a roadblock for the Big Three automakers to send their trucks for a similar pickup.  It’s as though Daddy has gotten his pink slip, albeit with a two-and-a-half-month notice, and has decided to empty out the family savings accounts and max out the credit cards before turning over control to the still-working Mommy.  “Here, dear, now you take over this mess,” Daddy says.  “Oh, and by the way, we’re flat broke, so I don’t want to hear about your children needing to go to the doctor or not getting adequate nutrition.  We can’t afford it.”

democrat-vs-republicanThere has been MUCH discussion among the pundits for the last several days about the idea of helping the Big Three with a “bridge loan” to get them through until things turn around.  Republicans are opposed to such an idea, and Democrats feel strongly that something must be done to save over 4 million jobs tied to the auto industry.  But in the noise that’s coming from pundits that like one-line sound bites expressing support for either solving or ignoring the problem, many SMALL details are getting very little discussion.  While everybody, especially those “aginners” who don’t want to help the poorly managed auto industry, blames management and labor unions for the entire mess, there have been a few voices on the other side with some important points to make.

Sen. Debbie Stabenow, D-Michigan

Sen. Debbie Stabenow, D-Michigan

Among the voices that should be listened to is that of Senator Debbie Stabenow (D-Michigan).  While it may be that she represents a vested interest group or two in the situation, she also brings forth some points that are being overlooked in the sound-bite discussions that are going on – you  know, the blame game that always comes along with any problem.  She pointed to three very real issues that I’m not hearing discussed by others.

The U.S., as the great proponent of free-market capitalism in the world, has basically set our automobile manufacturers up for failure.  While the Republican Administration has been helping their Big Oil buddies by encouraging consumption of big, gas-guzzling SUVs by their constituents, it has also required the U.S. auto industry to sink or swim on its own in the supposed free market of the world.  But is it really a free market?  Not really.

auto_industryWhile we have given our auto manufacturers too many passes at fuel efficiency standards, we have also refused to do anything as a government to help them be more competitive with their foreign counterparts.  While Japan, North Korea and Germany subsidized research and development into greater fuel efficiency, we called on our industry to pay its own way in R & D.  In addition, as the only industrial nation in the world to not provide health care to our citizens, we have forced that burden onto our car manufacturers while complaining about the high cost of it in doing business, blaming the unions for being unreasonable in their demands for health care benefits for their members.  While our international competitors in the marketplace imposed trade restrictions to protect their automakers from unfair outside competition, we have eschewed such  a thing as anti-capitalistic and against our free-trade principles.

Sen. Carl Levin, D-MI

Sen. Carl Levin, D-MI


Tavis Smiley

As a result of all of this ignorance of the realities of the international marketplace, our automakers are on the verge of collapse.  Like the glaring example of Hurricane Katrina, our government has been caught asleep at the helm yet again while a problem has gone from manageable to disastrous and self-destructive to our nation as a whole.  Tavis Smiley of PBS pointed out this morning on Meet the Press that Detroit is the poorest city in the United States, suffering unemployment near the one-third level.  Senator Carl Levin (D-Michigan), while on the same morning talk show, pointed out that the U.S. auto industry is indirectly connected to 10 percent of all American jobs and accounts for 20 percent of U.S. retail sales.  Those are staggering numbers that we ignore at our national peril.

Sen. Richard Shelby (R-Alabama)

Sen. Richard Shelby (R-Alabama)

On the other hand, we had Senator Richard Shelby (R-Alabama), who was opposed to any sort of help for the auto industry.  One only need look at the spectacularly successful economy in Alabama to see that Senator Shelby is someone we should all listen to.  Here is a man who ignores the abject poverty that has been a way of life in his home state, especially within the black minority population, over and over as he opposed every form of aid to anybody.  Yeah, I really care what Senator Shelby and his fellow Southern politicians offer as a prescription to the nation’s economic woes.  They have succeeded so well in helping their own that we should all sign on for some of that.


Dr. Phil McGraw

Dr. Phil McGraw

Unfortunately, we, as the step-children of one or the other of the two major political parties, are always caught in the insane middle of their petty arguments.  It’s time for Mommy and Daddy to realize that the house is burning down and somebody needs to call the fire department.  I hope that President-Elect Obama can truly bring some healing between Mommy and Daddy so that we step-children can find more security in our own home.  It’s time for a Dr. Phil moment in our nation where we can finally have a reality check.  “Hey, Mommy and Daddy, how’s that workin’ for you?”  Let’s keep praying they’ll wake up.


5 Comments leave one →
  1. 16 November 2008 5:54 pm

    Sigh…… Just when it seems that we have gotten our head above water a bit along comes the next wave to pull us back down again.

    Between news of racial incidents being at their highest after any Presidential election, along with record threats against our soon to be President, and the Auto Industry, I frankly feel like getting into my bed and pulling the covers over my head.

    Another great piece of investigative reporting Jack. Let’s keep up the good fight. We will need our strength…

  2. Left-Eyed Jack permalink*
    17 November 2008 11:21 am

    To: WillPen,

    Do not despair, somehow we will get through all of this. We always do. I NEVER thought we would get our government back after the re-election of George W. Bush, but we did. The greatest news that came out of this past election is that a working majority of the American people are a lot smarter than we thought.

    There will always be crazies on the fringe, but now we have the internet to keep them exposed. All we can do is use our sites to assist President Obama as he brings sanity back into our government.


  3. Drew Gamble permalink
    1 January 2010 12:44 am

    While I am not a gigantic fan of Sen. Richard Shelby, and because I have family in Alabama I am aware of the scourge of poverty in that state, I must nonetheless point out that during many periods, more cars are produced in Alabama than in Detroit. While the domestic auto manufacturers are in decline in the Midwest, foreign auto manufacturers are flourishing in the deep South. Honda, Subaru, Hyundai, Toyota, BWM, Mercedes are building cars in America – in the South. Shelby is a very negative guy and a bit of a blowhard, but this is an area where I think he and other southern politicians deserve more of a listen. Also, for the record, I came to this site accidentally while looking for a picture of Tavis Smiley, but your article was a good read, thanks.

    • 2 January 2010 1:20 pm

      Thanks for stopping by.

      While I will concede that a lot of cars are being manufactured in THE SOUTH, I will also point out that it is on the backs of the region’s poverty-stricken folks who are paying the taxes for those foreign manufacturers to “bless us” with their union-free jobs, which I might point out, ARE union jobs in their countries of origin. And pardon me if I refuse to give any politician much of a listen these days. I think they are ALL married to big business interests in this country at the expense of the majority of Americans who are suffering from the economic mess that THEY have caused.

      I wish you a happy New Year.


  1. My Kids; Your Kids

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: